Finding the right lawyer is not another complication.


Helping You Get Results



The Pros and Cons of Settling a Workers’ Compensation Claim

When an on-the-job injury leaves you in pain and unable to work, workers’ compensation can be a lifeline to cover medical bills and lost wages. However, the journey to recovery is not a well-paved highway; it is often a winding trail with forks in the road. Therefore, should you settle a worker’s compensation claim? In Colorado, there are distinct advantages and disadvantages to settling a workers’ compensation claim. Our experts at The Law Offices of W. Dan Mahoney, P.C. have explored the pros and cons to help you make an informed decision.

The Pros of Settling a Workers’ Compensation Claim

Workers Compensation

Some of the benefits of settling a worker’s compensation claim are;

Immediate Financial Relief

Settling a claim offers immediate relief, like a timely rescue amidst the financial storm caused by unexpected medical bills and the loss of wages. When you agree to a settlement, you receive a lump sum payment that can help cover medical bills and make up for lost wages. This can be valuable if you are facing financial hardships due to your injury.

Closure and Certainty

When you settle your claim, you will have a sense of closure. Dealing with the worker’s compensation process is often draining, and coming to an end of it lifts so much weight off your shoulders. Once you reach an agreement, you know exactly how much compensation you will receive, and the case is effectively closed. This can help reduce anxiety and allow you to move forward with your life.


You will have better control and flexibility over how you use the funds. You can allocate the settlement amount as you see fit. Whether you want to use it for ongoing medical treatment, vocational rehabilitation, or to address other pressing needs, it is all up to you. This flexibility can be particularly beneficial when you have unique circumstances and preferences.

Potentially Higher Total Compensation

In some cases, the total amount you receive through a settlement may be more substantial than what you would receive through ongoing wage replacement and medical benefits. This can be especially true if your injury has long-term consequences, as it accounts for future losses in a lump sum.

The Cons of Settling a Workers’ Compensation Claim

Some of the setbacks associated with settling a worker’s compensation claim include;

Reduced Long-Term Benefits

One of the most significant drawbacks of settling is that it often involves relinquishing your right to ongoing wage replacement and medical benefits. This means that if your injury or condition worsens over time, you cannot seek further compensation through the workers’ compensation system.

Medical Uncertainty

Settling a claim may leave you responsible for your future medical expenses related to the injury. This can be risky, as healthcare costs can be unpredictable and substantial. You may also need ongoing treatment or surgeries down the road.

Potential Undervaluation

Insurance companies may offer lower settlements than you deserve as they seek to save money. Without proper legal representation, you could accept an amount that doesn’t adequately cover your past and future costs. Having an experienced attorney can help you negotiate a fair settlement.

Considerations for Colorado Workers

Colorado has its own unique workers’ compensation laws, which can affect the pros and cons of settling a claim. Keep the following factors in mind if you are a Colorado worker:

  • Independent Medical Examinations (IMEs): In Colorado, insurance companies often request independent medical examinations to assess the extent of an injured worker’s impairment. These assessments can influence settlement negotiations, making it vital to have your own medical experts to provide a comprehensive evaluation of your condition.
  • Legal guidance: Given the complexities of Colorado’s workers’ compensation laws, seeking legal guidance is highly advisable. Our experienced attorneys at The Law Offices of W. Dan Mahoney, P.C. can help you understand the terms and negotiate a fair settlement.

The Decision to Settle Your Worker’s Compensation Claim

The decision to settle should be made carefully, fully understanding your rights and the specific circumstances surrounding your injury. At The Law Offices of W. Dan Mahoney, P.C., we are ready to help you make the best choice for your individual situation. Contact us for legal guidance today.